Today, I had the chance to speak to Greg Stewart with OMAFRA. Greg is the Corn Production Lead with OMFRA and runs the Ontario Corn Yield Trials.
The OCYT are conducted in 21 different plots separated into 7 different areas depending on heat units. The seed corn companies select and provide the hybrids for the trials. OMAFRA takes all the hybrids and randomizes them over three repetitions. Only two rows of the hybrid are planted, and both rows are harvested. The harvested length of the rows is about 20 feet. The average yield of the each plot is tallied and from there, the individual index for each hybrid is calculated.
A few thoughts to ponder on the trials:
1)Since the trial is randomized, you could have a very short hybrid beside a tall one resulting in less sunlight for the short one. You would therefor have a lower index of the shaded hybrid on the two rows harvested than in a full scale field trial. Greg did mention that next year, there will be four rows of each hybrid planted and only the centre two rows will be harvested for the index. This will eliminate some of the shade effect.
2) Twenty feet of two rows harvested is 0.0023 acres. Since there is 100+ hybrids in the OCYT, I understand that there is no way to harvest any larger area per Hybrid. Randomizing the three repetitions does help to eliminate field variability but not all of it.
I am not discounting the OCYT, they are a great tool to use and Greg and his team put a lot of work into planning, planting, harvesting and tallying the results. The OCYT should be just one of many tools used to come to a decision on what hybrid is best for your farm - not the only one.
The OCYT are conducted in 21 different plots separated into 7 different areas depending on heat units. The seed corn companies select and provide the hybrids for the trials. OMAFRA takes all the hybrids and randomizes them over three repetitions. Only two rows of the hybrid are planted, and both rows are harvested. The harvested length of the rows is about 20 feet. The average yield of the each plot is tallied and from there, the individual index for each hybrid is calculated.
A few thoughts to ponder on the trials:
1)Since the trial is randomized, you could have a very short hybrid beside a tall one resulting in less sunlight for the short one. You would therefor have a lower index of the shaded hybrid on the two rows harvested than in a full scale field trial. Greg did mention that next year, there will be four rows of each hybrid planted and only the centre two rows will be harvested for the index. This will eliminate some of the shade effect.
2) Twenty feet of two rows harvested is 0.0023 acres. Since there is 100+ hybrids in the OCYT, I understand that there is no way to harvest any larger area per Hybrid. Randomizing the three repetitions does help to eliminate field variability but not all of it.
I am not discounting the OCYT, they are a great tool to use and Greg and his team put a lot of work into planning, planting, harvesting and tallying the results. The OCYT should be just one of many tools used to come to a decision on what hybrid is best for your farm - not the only one.
